|
|
||||||||
Ecology |
Department of Biology, Box 355325, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195-5325 USA
Received for publication March 10, 2004. Accepted for publication September 16, 2004.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: community assembly dispersal Mount St. Helens primary succession refugia vegetation dynamics volcano
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Landscape ecologists emphasize that surviving vegetation can sustain biodiversity (Turner and Corlett, 1996
). Existing vegetation often survives disturbances, may accelerate recovery (Rundgren and Ingolfsson, 1999
; Poulin et al., 1999
), or at least promote colonization (Brunet and von Oheimb, 1998
). Therefore, learning how rich resource patches affect recovery of vegetation informs our understanding of community development. Studies of the assembly of plant communities often describe cases where dispersal limits affect species composition (Primack & Miao, 1992
; Kochy and Rydin, 1997
; Erikkson, 2000
; Zobel et al., 2000
; Costa et al., 2003
; Foster and Tilman, 2003
; Wehncke et al., 2003
). However, the degree to which distance from propagule sources affects species composition remains poorly understood. Colonization requires dispersal and establishment. Dispersal abilities vary, so isolation from propagule sources can shape early community composition and create gradients of richness and cover (Borgegärd, 1990
; Stöcklin and Bäumler, 1996
; del Moral et al., in press
). Plants with light, windborne seeds often dominate early succession (Prach and Py
ek, 1999
), especially on volcanoes (del Moral and Grishin, 1999
). However, survival of these species is low, while poorly dispersed, large-seeded species establish well (Wood and del Moral, 1987
, 1988
).
Here we explore the effects of two contrasting habitats on Mount St. Helens. Refugia permitted the survival of forest understory species in soil due to steep northeast-facing slopes and a deep snow pack (Fuller and del Moral, 2003
). However, refugia did not contribute relict species to the adjacent vegetation. Instead, refugia provided habitats for newly invading species to establish dense populations from which to expand. Fuller and del Moral (2003)
also found that expansion from refugia on Mount St. Helens resulted in major changes in dispersal spectra over short distances. They predicted that sites near refugia would become more similar to distant sites over time. We also explored dispersal spectra near small, isolated wetlands formed soon after the eruption on pyroclastic materials north of the crater (del Moral, 1999b
) to determine if there is a more general effect of dense vegetation on the surroundings.
This study searches for patterns associated with biologically rich patches represented by refugia and wetlands. By looking at the spatial effects of different types of dense vegetation we hope to better understand the mechanisms driving vegetation change.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Wetlands
The 16 sampled wetlands were within a 1-km2 area south of Spirit Lake (between 46°15'34'' N, 122°09'42'' W and 46°15'00'' N, 122°09'45'' W). These wetlands formed in depressions on pyroclastic material (del Moral et al., 1995
; Titus et al., 1999
; del Moral, 1999b
). They are supported by snow that collects in depressions and by upwelling seeps. Transects were established on homogeneous surfaces that have experienced wind erosion since 1980 to form a coarse surface. Subsurface materials were much finer than that of transects above refugia. Transects extended to 32 m.
Comparison
Many characteristics of refugia, wetlands, and their transects were similar (Table 1), but these patches differed in significant ways. Wetlands were about 250 m lower in elevation. Refugia contain old soil on steep slopes, while wetlands formed shortly after the 1980 eruption in depressions. Transects above refugia sample pumice that has decomposed, while those extending from wetlands occur on eroded pyroclastic materials. Wetland soils were similar in organic content, but higher in pH than the refugia soils.
|
Each wetland was sampled using two or three transects that included two quadrats 1 m inside the wetland and 1-m2 samples starting at 1, 2, 3, 4, 8, 12, 16, and 32 m. The edge was determined using lack of saturation at the surface and rarity of obligate wetland species. Species nomenclature is that found in the Integrated Taxonomic Information System (ITIS; http:// www.itis.usda.gov).
Data summary
Structure
The number of species (richness), their percent cover, and two measures of vegetation structure were calculated for each sample unit and for pooled data (e.g., all samples at 2 m from a refugium). We used the complement of Simpson's dominance index [D = (1
pi2)], which varies from 0 to 1. It is insensitive to small samples and rare species. The Shannon Index (H' =
pilnpi) balances the number of species and their relative abundances. In both cases, pi is the proportion of the cover represented by a species. These measures were calculated using PC-ORD (McCune and Mefford, 1999
).
Floristic similarity
The floristic relationship between two samples was quantified using percent similarity [PSij = 200
min (Xik, Xjk)/
(Xik + Xjk), where there are k species, X is percent cover, and min is the lower value (Kovach, 1998
)]. Similarity among samples of a year was calculated from 4-m2 plots (N = 37 in 1997; N = 32 in 2002).
Dispersal types
Fuller and del Moral (2003)
divided species by their likely dominant dispersal vector. We modified this classification by considering spore-producing species separately. We added species found in wetlands to form additional categories (Table 2).
|
Statistical analyses
One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and the conservative Bonferroni test of differences among the means were used to detect differences among structural parameters along distance gradients. Regressions of structural measures with distance were calculated where appropriate, and the slopes and intercepts of individual regressions were compared. All statistical procedures were conducted using Statistix (Analytical Software, 2001
). Graphs were prepared with Axum 7 (Mathsoft, 2001
).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Percent similarity (PS) among sample pairs of each transect was calculated from 4-m2 samples (see Methods). The rectangles sampled in 1997 show more variation than did the quadrats of 2002. Therefore, the similarity among adjacent samples was higher than had the sampling been conducted with 4-m2 quadrats. The distance between each sample in 1997 was 1 m, while in 2002 it was either 2 or 4 m. This also reduced the similarity between 2002 samples.
In both 1997 and 2002, individual transects reflected the floristic gradient described by ordinations. PS between the nearest samples (A and B) did not differ between years, though the higher value in 1997 may be due to the sampling artifacts, to greater richness, or to more uncommon species in 2002. The 2002 PS comparisons between B and C and B and D, and C to D were more similar than those comparisons in 1997.
Nearby samples were all compared to distant ones. Similarities of samples A-1997 through D-1997 to the barrens ranged from 15 to 19%. In 2002, the comparison of samples A-2002 to D-2002 to the 64-m and to the 128-m samples ranged from 20 to 39%. The 2002 PS were significantly higher than the 1997 PS (t-test) except in one comparison to the 2 m distance (Table 3). Species better adapted to life on the barrens, particularly those with larger seeds in the tumbler and barren other group, were becoming more widely distributed. These species included Agrostis spp., Penstemon cardwellii, Luetkea pectinata, Lupinus lepidus, and Saxifraga ferruginea, species that were common in barren sites in 1997.
|
|
Comparisons between the 1997 and the 2002 transects confirmed that the vegetation had developed substantially. Structural features were compared as with the similarity comparisons. The 2002 data reflected greater structural development near the refugia (Table 4), as well as at greater distances. Mean richness was higher, often statistically significantly so, in 2002. Cover, not subject to the sampling bias, was higher in each comparison. H' and D also tended to be higher in 2002, indicating reduced dominance as rarer species have expanded on the transects.
|
Distribution of dispersal types
Patterns observed here should reflect dispersal and the ability of a species to persist and expand. The distributions of species along transects were analyzed using one of seven dispersal categories. Refugia were dominated by bird-dispersed species and mesophytic herbs with poor dispersal. The inclusion of refugia data guarantees large differences along transects, so refugia were excluded from statistical analyses. The maximum cover of each dispersal category was next to the refugia. Cover declined with distance, but dispersal types declined to different degrees, all of which were significant (Fig. 4). Wind-dispersed species (parachute, glider, tumbler) all declined sharply, reaching a "baseline" between 16 and 24 m. Thereafter, other factors dictated the details of species composition. Bird-dispersed species dropped to near zero within 4 m, while species dispersed by other means (primarily Aruncus viridus and Lupinus latifolius) occurred up to 16 m from refugia.
|
Distribution of typical species
The distributions of species reflect the patterns of dispersal. The species present were drawn from among those common on the barrens. Cover of parachute species declined with distance (Fig. 6), due to low background seed rain (Wood and del Moral, 2000
) and because early colonists have become senescent. They formed a very small fraction of the total beyond 32 m. Many other wind dispersed species were abundant in and immediately adjacent to refugia (Fig. 7). They all declined with distance, but not to the same degree as parachute species. Lupinus lepidus did not invade refugia or their margins. Though uncommon in 1997, it subsequently expanded rapidly on the Pumice Plains (Bishop, 2002
). Seedling establishment has declined in recent years because safe sites have been usurped by long-lived species or have disappeared as erosion and weathering reduce the physical habitat complexity of the pumice barrens. This phenomenon helps species that spread vigorously.
|
Wetlands
Floristic patterns
The wetlands data were analyzed by NMS, which indicated that there was only one dimension of floristic change. The DCA axes were strongly correlated with distance (r2 = 0.47; log-linear regression P << 0.0001), so we used distance rather than the statistical construct.
DCA identified a strong floristic gradient from the wetlands to dry uplands. The correlation between distance from 1 to 32 m and DCA-1 on each surface was significant (r2 = 0.84; P < 0.005). Herbaceous wetland species, such as Typha, Juncus spp., Equisetum spp., and wetland mosses, were dominant, with scattered Salix spp. Though physiographically similar, the flora of these wetlands differed greatly. Unlike wetlands associated with perennial streams on the Pumice Plain, Salix and Alnus were not dominant (del Moral, 1999b
). Cover of most species declined with distance from wetlands, but Lupinus lepidus increased substantially and upland mosses were variable from 1 to 32 m. These species, however, are unlikely to benefit directly from wetland effects. Rather, they were common throughout the area. Most other upland species displayed lower cover with distance from the wetlands. These included widely distributed parachute species such as Epilobium anagallidifolium, Hypochaeris, Salix commutata, Carex mertensii, Juncus mertensianus, Castilleja miniata, and Anaphalis. Many wetland species also expanded slightly beyond the wetland into plots dominated by upland species that were dry on the surface during sampling. These included Salix sitchensis and Epilobium ciliatum, which declined gradually to 16 m, Juncus articulatus and Equisetum arvense, which extended to 4 m, and mosses and liverworts found up to 2 m distant.
Vegetation structure
Richness declined steadily along the transect, continuing until a baseline appeared to be reached beyond 16 m (Fig. 9). Cover declined sharply beyond the wetland, but none of the sites beyond 1 m differed significantly from one another. However, when the cover of Lupinus lepidus and upland mosses was excluded, there is a strong pattern of decline that continued to 32 m. We excluded these widely distributed species because they do not appear to require soil development on the Pumice Plain (del Moral and Jones, 2002
). They, therefore, could mask facilitation effects of the wetland.
|
|
|
Species with other dispersal mechanisms included Lupinus lepidus, other pioneer species, and species of refugia, declined. Other species with poor dispersal found in refugia extended to 12 m at levels above background and may be enjoying facilitation from wetland effects. There does not appear to be an effect on pioneer species (Fig. 14). These patterns are summarized in terms of relative cover (Fig. 15). The proportion of most dispersal types declined with distance from the wetland due to the increasing cover of upland mosses.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The environments near refugia and near wetlands do not change significantly, yet DCA reveals that the vegetation changes gradationally. This implies that much of the immigration is linked to the refugia or wetlands. This is weak evidence that "hot spots" influence the direction of primary succession. Plants found on the margins of patches likely produced the majority of seedlings of most species found within 16 m. This effect attenuates with distance, so that beyond 32 m, invasion is dominated by species from the general seed rain.
Species composition changes
Soon after the 1980 eruption, parachute species found a suitable habitat on edges of refugia and soon produced copious seeds. This translated into relatively dense populations of parachute species (e.g., near refugia Anaphalis, Chamerion, Hieracium, Hypochaeris; Fuller and del Moral, 2003
). In contrast, some species, including Lupinus lepidus, Luetkea pectinata, Juncus mertensianus, J. parryi, Saxifraga ferruginea, Cistanthe umbellata, and Salix commutata, have patterns that are irregular with respect to refugia. These species are more likely to have invaded from the general seed rain. Lupinus lepidus, in particular, established in concentrated patches over much of the Pumice Plain in areas far removed from refugia. By 2002, proportions in the barrens had changed significantly. Within 20 m of the refugia, parachute species, gliders, and tumblers declined, while pioneers increased. These patterns suggest that the advantages offered by refugia on wind-dispersed species are overcome by the slower dispersing, more persistent species.
The pattern differs subtly with respect to wetlands. Unlike the margins of refugia, wetland margins present a strongly contrasting environment to the barrens. Soils are wetter, shade is more common, and competition is more intense. The wetlands were invaded soon after the eruption, primarily by mosses, horsetails, small-seeded rushes, and some willows (Titus et al., 1999
), as well as upland parachute species. Isolated wetlands did not support dense willow populations, and did not cast much shade beyond the wetland. Upland parachute species declined with respect to wetlands, reaching a baseline within 16 m. Species such as Hypochaeris, Salix commutata, and Chamerion were abundant near the edges of wetlands and, presumably, have expanded from these founder populations, much as parachute species have done from refugia. Gliders and tumblers were erratic with respect to wetlands. However, species with other dispersal mechanisms, such as Luzula, Castilleja, Juncus mertensianus, and wetland species declined regularly from peaks near the wetland. Of these species, all but Hypochaeris do best in moist environments. Lupinus lepidus increased dramatically from wetlands, suggesting that it is not benefited from wetland effects.
Dispersal-type changes
The two core habitats were dominated by different concentrations of dispersal types (Figs. 16 17). Wetlands and nearby barrens had substantially more parachute species and abundant spore plants, but parachutists were not so dominant near refugia. This effect is due primarily to the abundance of Hypochaeris radicata and Salix commutata surrounding wetlands. Spore-bearing plants were also more abundant surrounding wetlands. Wetland mosses and ferns expanded to some degree beyond wetlands, while upland species were particularly common. Upland mosses increased proportionately along refugia transects because other species declined in the harsher pumice. Gliding species were relatively sparse in both samples. Tumblers were more abundant, and increased to a greater degree around refugia than wetlands. This effect may be due to the greater abundance of Agrostis and Penstemon at higher elevations and the stronger winds in the vicinity of the refugia transects. In addition, soils surrounding wetlands were derived from pyroclastic materials and are less stable than the pumice found above the refugia. This may limit the ability of these species to establish. Bird dispersed species did not extend far from the wetlands or the refugia. Species common to refugia and wetlands with limited dispersal dropped off rapidly in both cases. Pioneer species lacking obvious dispersal mechanisms increased dramatically outside wetlands, less so above the refugia. The contrasting nature of these habitats, and their contrasting landscape positions appear to translate into different types of floristic gradients around biologically rich habitats.
|
Similarity
Vegetation developed significantly between 1997 and 2002 on the barrens transects. Within 20 m of refugia, where floristic gradients are strongest, similarities between adjacent samples have increased markedly. Thus the vegetation is becoming more homogeneous. It is unlikely that this process will lead to high levels of similarity because herbaceous and low shrub vegetation responds to many variables that maintain heterogeneity. These include habitat variations (del Moral, 1993
), recurrent disturbances, and localized herbivory. Increasing similarity between samples adjacent to refugia and more distant barrens implies that competitive effects and persistence of a few species are beginning to override the effects of local dispersal due to refugia. From 1997, parachute species (excluding spore bearing species) declined in absolute cover from 1.40 to 0.70%. Gliders did not change (0.45 in 1997, 0.43 in 2002), while tumblers increased from 2.00 to 3.57%. Other pioneer species increased strongly from 0.30 to 4.26%. Longer lived, larger, and more persistent species are exerting dominance over parachute species that were able to colonize barrens soon after the eruption by building up populations on refugia margins.
Structural changes
The central question of this study is whether productive sites can enhance the vegetation of their surroundings by providing an initial pulse of seedlings. Clearly both refugia and wetlands do. There are floristic gradients leading from both, and both total cover and species richness decline with distance from these patches. On the barrens, cover does not change significantly beyond 24 m, and major effects may not extend beyond 8 m. Surrounding wetlands, the effect may extend no more than 16 m. Richness near refugia and wetlands was not affected beyond 16 m.
Diversity measures confirmed the limited scope of productive site effects. H' and D both declined sharply away from refugia as the number of species declined and a few species became dominant. On the wetland, both H' and D declined sharply to the end of the transect, at values lower than the lowest on the barrens. The pattern was similar after excluding the effects of Lupinus lepidus and upland mosses.
Clearly, the effects of productive sites of contrasting types are weak beyond 16 m. As yet, vegetation has not developed attractions for birds at greater distances that would alter this condition. Bird-dispersed species are notably lacking from plots even 8 m from productive sites. When perches become available, we predict that community development will accelerate.
Implications
This study provides insight into the importance of remnant vegetation. While remnants serve an important function during early primary succession, their effects are indirect. Surviving species fail to invade surrounding barren sites, but refugia and wetland provide oases for the rapid establishment of species capable of long-distance dispersal. It is these pioneering species that reproduce and disperse into the surroundings. Restoration ecologists are aware of the importance of dispersal for recovery. Here, we demonstrate that over ten to 20 years, short distances from potential colonists impede establishment. There were pronounced gradients in dispersal types surrounding both a remnant habitat and new wetlands. Though they differed in detail, the effects of both habitats were limited to less than 30 m. Such limitations must be considered in planning rehabilitation or restoration and for studying the effects of landscape fragmentation. The paucity of successful invasion events in a hostile habitat also implies that migration rates of many species, in the face of global warming, may be less than anticipated by many dispersal models.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
2 Author for correspondence (moral{at}u.washington.edu
.) ![]()
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Anderson E. C. Nilsson M. E. Johansson 2000 Plant dispersal in boreal rivers and its relation to the diversity of riparian flora. Journal of Biogeography 27: 1095-1106[CrossRef][ISI]
Bishop J. G. 2002 Early primary succession on Mount St. Helens: impact of insect herbivores on colonizing lupines. Ecology 83: 191-202[ISI]
Borgegärd S. O. 1990 Vegetation development in abandoned gravel pits: effects of surrounding vegetation, substrate and regionally. Journal of Vegetation Science 1: 675-682[CrossRef][ISI]
Brunet J. G. von Oheimb 1998 Migration of vascular plants to secondary woodlands in southern Sweden. Journal of Ecology 86: 429-438[CrossRef]
Costa B. S. B. J. C. Marangoni A. M. G. Azevedo 2003 Plant zonation in irregularly flooded salt marshes: relative importance of stress tolerance and biological interactions. Journal of Ecology 91: 951-965[CrossRef]
del Moral R. 1993 Mechanisms of primary succession on volcanoes: a view from Mount St. Helens. In J. Miles and D. H. Walton [eds.], Primary succession on land, 79100. Blackwell Scientific Publications, London, UK
del Moral R. 1999a Plant succession on pumice at Mount St. Helens. American Midland Naturalist 141: 101-114[CrossRef][ISI]
del Moral R. 1999b Predictability of primary successional wetlands on pumice, Mount St. Helens. Madroño 46: 177-186
del Moral R. S. Y. Grishin 1999 Volcanic disturbances and ecosystem recovery. In L. R. Walker [ed.], Ecosystems of disturbed ground, ecosystems of the world 16, 137160. Elsevier Publishers, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
del Moral R. C. C. Jones 2002 Vegetation development on pumice at Mount St. Helens, USA. Plant Ecology 162: 9-22[CrossRef][ISI]
del Moral R. J. H. Titus A. M. Cook 1995 Early primary succession on Mount St. Helens, Washington, USA. Journal of Vegetation Science 6: 107-120
del Moral R. D. M. Wood J. H. Titus In press Proximity, microsites, and biotic interactions during early primary succession. In V. H. Dale, F. J. Swanson, and C. M. Crisafulli. Ecological recovery after the 1980 eruptions of Mount St. Helens, Ch. 7. Springer-Verlag, New York, New York, USA
Eriksson O. 2000 Seed dispersal and colonization ability of plantsassessment and implications for conservation. Folia Geobotanica 35: 115-123[CrossRef][ISI]
Foster B. L. D. Tilman 2003 Seed limitation and the regulation of community structure in oak savanna grassland. Journal of Ecology 91: 999-1007[CrossRef]
Fuller R. N. 1999 The role of refugia in primary succession on Mount St. Helens, Washington. Master's thesis, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA
Fuller R. N. R. del Moral 2003 The role of refugia and dispersal in primary succession on Mount St. Helens, Washington. Journal of Vegetation Science 14: 637-644[CrossRef][ISI]
Kochy M. H. Rydin 1997 Biogeography of vascular plants on habitat islands, peninsulas and main lands in an east-central Swedish agricultural landscape. Nordic Journal of Botany 17: 215-223
Kovach W. L. 1998 MVSPa multivariate statistical package for Windows, version 3.0. Kovach Computing Services, Pentraeth, Wales, UK
Mathsoft. 2001 Axum 7 for Windows user's guide. Insightful Corporation, Seattle, Washington, USA
McCune B. J. B. Grace 2002 Analysis of ecological communities. MjM Software Design, Gleneden Beach, Oregon, USA
McCune B. M. J. Mefford 1999 PC-ORD, multivariate analysis of ecological data, version 4.0. MjM Software Design, Gleneden Beach, Oregon, USA
Poulin M. L. Rochefort A. Desrochers 1999 Conservation of bog plant assemblages: assessing the role of natural remnants in mined sites. Applied Vegetation Science 2: 169-180[CrossRef]
Prach K. P. Py
ek 1999 How do species dominating in succession differ from others?. Journal of Vegetation Science 10: 383-392[CrossRef][ISI]
Primack R. B. S. L. Miao 1992 Dispersal can limit local plant distribution. Conservation Biology 6: 513-519[CrossRef][ISI]
Rundgren M. O. Ingolfsson 1999 Plant survival in Iceland during periods of glaciation. Journal of Biogeography 26: 387-396[CrossRef][ISI]
Stöcklin J. E. Bäumler 1996 Seed rain, seedling establishment and clonal growth strategies on a glacier foreland. Journal of Vegetation Science 7: 45-56
Titus J. H. P. J. Titus R. del Moral 1999 Wetland development in primary and secondary successional substrates: fourteen years after the eruption of Mount St. Helens, Washington, USA. Northwest Science 73: 186-204[ISI]
Turner I. M. R. T. Corlett 1996 The conservation value of small, isolated fragments of lowland tropical rain forest. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 11: 330-333[CrossRef]
Walker L. R. R. del Moral 2003 Primary succession and ecosystem rehabilitation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Wehncke E. V. S. P. Hubbell R. B. Foster J. W. Dalling 2003 Seed dispersal patterns produced by white-faced monkeys: implications for the dispersal limitation of neotropical tree species. Journal of Ecology 91: 677-685
Wood D. M. R. del Moral 1987 Mechanisms of early primary succession in subalpine habitats on Mount St. Helens. Ecology 68: 780-790[CrossRef][ISI]
Wood D. M. R. del Moral 1988 Colonizing plants on the Pumice Plains, Mount St. Helens, Washington. American Journal of Botany 75: 1228-1237[CrossRef][ISI]
Wood D. M. R. del Moral 2000 Seed rain during early primary succession on Mount St. Helens, Washington. Madroño 47: 1-9
Zobel M. M. Otusus J. Liira M. Moora T. Möls 2000 Is small-scale species richness limited by seed availability or microsite availability. Ecology 81: 3274-3282[CrossRef][ISI]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. del Moral and I. L. Lacher Vegetation patterns 25 years after the eruption of Mount St. Helens, Washington, USA Am. J. Botany, December 1, 2005; 92(12): 1948 - 1956. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |