Am. J. Bot. Join BSA Today!
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Submit a response
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me when eLetters are posted
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (16)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Brewer, J. S.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Brewer, J. S.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Brewer, J. S.
(American Journal of Botany. 2001;88:1250-1257.)
© 2001 Botanical Society of America, Inc.


Ecology

A demographic analysis of fire-stimulated seedling establishment of Sarracenia alata (Sarraceniaceae)1

J. Stephen Brewer2

Department of Biology, University of Mississippi, University, Mississippi 38677 USA

Received for publication June 27, 2000. Accepted for publication December 22, 2000.


    ABSTRACT
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 LITERATURE CITED
 
Recurring fires are thought to be critical to maintaining populations of carnivorous plants in wet pine savannas. Nevertheless, the impact of fire on population dynamics of these unique and sometimes rare plants is poorly understood. In this study, I analyzed stage-structured matrices for Sarracenia alata. To examine the effects of fire-stimulated increases in seedling establishment, five matrices were constructed, which differed in fecundity rates associated with different fire frequencies (annual fires, 1/3, 1/7, 1/20, and 0/20 yr). In addition, I analyzed the sensitivity of population growth and dynamics to changes in other vital rates. Fire-stimulated increases in fecundity were not necessary to maintain viable populations of Sarracenia alata. Although increases in fecundity increased population growth rate, all five fire frequencies (including the "no-fire" scenario) produced either stationary or increasing populations. Adding year-to-year stochasticity in vital rates did not alter these general trends. Population growth and decline were much more sensitive to reductions in the survival of large adult ramets (which were projected to have a life expectancy of 59 yr). Population growth was also more sensitive to changes in juvenile persistence than to juvenile growth, suggesting that conservative use of captured resources by juveniles has a greater impact on fitness than rapid growth and maturation. Given that a previous study showed that modest variation in fire frequency had no impact on either adult or juvenile survival, I conclude that Sarracenia alata relies on fire-regulated plasticity in allocation to pitchers to increase the survival and lifetime fecundity of iteroparous ramets.

Key Words: bog • life history • matrix models • pitcher plants • population dynamics • sensitivity analysis


    INTRODUCTION
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 LITERATURE CITED
 
Frequent fires play a critical role in the maintenance of plant species diversity in pine savannas by reducing rates of competitive displacement (Walker and Peet, 1983 ; Norquist, 1984 ; Gilliam and Christensen, 1986 ; Waldrop, White, and Jones, 1992 ; Brockway and Lewis, 1997 ; Maliakal, Menges, and Denslow, 2000 ). Carnivorous plants are thought to be particularly vulnerable to competitive displacement in unburned seepage bogs and wet pine savannas of the southeastern coastal plain of the United States (Wells, 1928 ; Wells and Skunk, 1928 ; Eleuterius, 1968 ; McDaniel, 1971 ; Schnell, 1976 ; Weiss, 1980 ; Folkerts, 1982 ; Gibson, 1983 ; Barker and Williamson, 1988 ). Previous studies have shown that foliage of pitcher plants (Sarracenia spp.) and seedling densities of pitcher plants and sundews (Drosera capillaris) increase dramatically following winter fires (Eleuterius, 1968 ; Weiss, 1980 ; Barker and Williamson 1988 ; Brewer, 1999a, b ). A cost–benefit model (Givnish et al., 1984 ) predicts that carnivorous plants would be at a competitive disadvantage in low-light environments as aboveground biomass and litter increase during prolonged intervals between fires (Givnish et al., 1984 ). The benefit of producing carnivorous structures declines as growth becomes limited more by light than by the availability of nutrients (Givnish et al., 1984 ). Thus, both theory and empirical observations would appear to support the idea that carnivorous plants benefit from frequent fires.

As important as frequent fires may be in maintaining species diversity in pine savannas, short-term increases in foliage and seedling densities following fire do not provide adequate proof that frequent fires are necessary to maintain populations of carnivorous plants. Fire-stimulated increases in foliage may indicate shifts in allocation rather than increases in growth or density (Brewer, 1999a ). Furthermore, just because individual fires increase seedling establishment does not mean that frequent fires are necessary to maintain viable populations. The viability and duration of dormant or semi-dormant stages may enable carnivorous plants to escape competition during fire-free intervals. Small, short-lived species such as Drosera capillaris and Utricularia spp. apparently escape competition by producing a persistent seed bank (Brewer, 1999b, c ; Maliakal, Menges, and Denslow, 2000 ; J. S. Brewer, unpublished data). Long-lived perennial plants such as Sarracenia spp. may avoid competition by reducing allocation to costly pitchers during years without fire (Brewer, 1999a ). There are no studies of the real impact of fire-mediated changes in seedling establishment or pitcher production on pitcher-plant populations. And yet, numerous authors cite declines in the density of pitchers and seedlings with fire suppression as evidence that frequent fires are necessary to maintain populations of carnivorous plants (Eleuterius, 1968 ; Weiss, 1980 ; Folkerts, 1982 ; Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; Givnish, 1989 ).

Ideally, one would use long-term controlled experiments to test the effects of fire frequency on the growth and viability of carnivorous-plant populations. Unfortunately, such data are not currently available. Another approach is to model long-term population dynamics using responses to one or a few individual fires. Although this approach has been used to model the effects of fire regime on pine and oak populations in xeric longleaf pine systems (e.g., Rebertus, Williamson, and Moser, 1989 ), such an approach has not been used in hydric pine–savanna systems (e.g., pitcher-plant bogs). Matrix models can provide reasonable projections of population dynamics into the future, given a number of contingencies within realistic bounds (Caswell, 1989 ). The validity of model results could be tested and the models refined as experimental data become available.

In this study, I examined the potential impact of fire frequency on population dynamics of Sarracenia alata (Wood) Wood (yellow pitcher plant, hereafter Sarracenia) in pitcher plant bogs in southeastern Mississippi, USA. I chose to study this species for three reasons. First, Sarracenia exhibits fire-stimulated seedling establishment (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; J. S. Brewer, Laws, and Mozingo, unpublished data). Second, others have argued that populations of Sarracenia decline in the absence of fire (Eleuterius, 1968 ; Folkerts, 1982 ; Barker and Williamson, 1988 ). Third, Sarracenia alata is a common species that exhibits a morphology and life history similar to rare congeneric species of pitcher plants (e.g., S. leucophylla, S. oreophila). It therefore provides a model to guide studies of the ecology and natural history of rare species of pitcher plants.

The objectives of the current study were threefold. First, I summarized demographic data collected in the current and previous studies (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; Brewer, 1999a ) in the form of stage-structured Lefkovitch matrices. Second, I examined the effects of fire-stimulated increases in seedling establishment on population growth. Third, I performed elasticity and stochastic sensitivity analyses of vital rates of stage-structured populations subjected to different hypothetical fire regimes. In particular, I examined the impact of changes in adult persistence, juvenile persistence, and juvenile growth on population growth and viability.


    MATERIALS AND METHODS
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 LITERATURE CITED
 
Life cycle of Sarracenia
Sarracenia alata is a long-lived rhizomatous perennial herb (for more details on its biology, see Brewer, 1999a ). The stages of its life cycle I recognized as important in the current study are presented in a life-cycle diagram (Fig. 1). These stages were based on size, specifically the diameter of the largest pitcher (see Brewer, 1999a ; Fig. 1). I used biological differences in choosing these size classes. Seedlings were considered recent germinants or small 1-yr-old juveniles. Seedlings were entire genets whose largest pitcher was <4 mm in diameter at the keel of the lip. Juveniles were entire genets whose largest pitcher was ≥4 mm but <10 mm in diameter. A fundamental difference between seedlings and juveniles is that exclusion of prey from pitchers of juveniles potentially reduces growth rate, whereas prey exclusion has no significant effect on seedlings (J. S. Brewer, unpublished data). Small adults were ramets whose largest pitcher was ≥10 mm but <20 mm in diameter (or <30 cm in length). This minimum threshold corresponded to the smallest ramets I had observed flowering. Large adults were all ramets whose largest pitcher was ≥20 mm in diameter or ≥30 cm in length. Large adult ramets also were observed to produce daughter rhizomes, whereas small adult ramets typically did not.



View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 1. Life-cycle diagram of Sarracenia alata. Stage 1 represents seedlings (diameter of the largest pitcher [pd] < 4 mm). Stage 2 is juveniles (4 ≤ pd < 10 mm). Stage 3 is small adults (10 ≤ pd < 20 mm). Stage 4 is large adults (pd ≥ 20 mm)

 
Four categories of vital rates were calculated for this species, Fi (fecundity), Gi (proportion of individuals that grow from stage i to the next larger stage, Pi (proportion of individuals that remain in stage i), and V (vegetative reproduction rate or the transition from large adults to small adults). Growth into the next larger size class and persistence within the same size class were calculated directly from repeated annual measurements of pitcher diameter of marked individuals. Vegetative reproduction was determined from excavated transplants (Brewer, 1999a ). Because rates of vegetative reproduction were low, I had few demographic data on vegetative recruits. For this reason they were lumped together with small adult ramets. As more data become available vegetative recruits could be treated as distinct from small adults. All vital rates are shown in Table 1.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 1. Stage-structured projection matrix showing mean vital rates (standard deviations in parentheses)

 
Seeds of this species do not accumulate in a persistent (i.e., between-year) seed bank, nor do they require special fire-related cues to stimulate germination (Ellison, 2001; J. S. Brewer, Laws, and Mozingo, unpublished data). Consequently, fecundity was quantified by determining the transition from small or large adults in one year to seedlings in the following year. Although seedling densities are typically higher at recently burned sites than at unburned sites (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; J. S. Brewer, Laws, and Mozingo, unpublished data), fires apparently do not increase rates of germination (Ellison, 2001 ; J. S. Brewer, Laws, and Mozingo, unpublished data).

Sources of data for matrices
I generated stage-structured matrices (Lefkovitch, 1965 ) from averages of vital rates based on 2, or in the case of survivorship, 3 yr of demographic data from a population that was burned, on average, once every 3 yr. This fire-return interval is typical of populations at the University of Mississippi Forest Lands (hereafter, UMFL), most of which have received regular prescribed burning since the early 1980s. I used data collected in the current study and previous studies (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; Brewer, 1999a ). A previous experiment showed that individual winter fires had no significant effect on means or variances of growth, survivorship, or sexual or vegetative reproduction of transplants beyond the seedling stage (Brewer, 1999a ). I used demographic data obtained from Brewer (1999a) to calculate vital rates associated with vegetative reproduction and survivorship of seedlings, juveniles, and adults in two consecutive years. I used data obtained from Barker and Williamson's (1988) study of the same species in a similar habitat to calculate vital rates associated with fecundity.

In the current study, I collected a third year of data on growth and survivorship of seedlings and post-seedling juveniles and adults. I marked and monitored 80 plants each of seedlings, juveniles, small adults, and large adults from May 1998 to May 1999 (see Brewer, 1999a , for details on study sites and censusing procedure).

The transition from adult ramet to seedling (i.e., fecundity) was obtained from data presented in Barker and Williamson (1988) . I used their data because they collected fecundity data from replicate burned and unburned plots (8 x 8 m), whereas I only have data from unburned sites. Barker and Williamson's data on fecundity from their unburned control plots were similar to what I estimated at my field sites. I calculated the transitions from established ramets ("buds" cf. Barker and Williamson, 1988 ) to seedlings in burned and unburned plots. These averages of fecundity were then used to calculate stage-specific fecundities for small and large adult ramets.

Fecundity was assumed to vary from year to year according to the proportion of ramets that flowered in the year preceding seedling emergence (see Barker and Williamson, 1988 ). Seedling densities were highly correlated with the incidence of flowering in the previous year (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; J. S. Brewer, unpublished data). Year-to-year variation in flowering percentages of adults was obtained from Barker and Williamson (1988) . These authors found the incidence of flowering varied considerably among years (32.5%). This magnitude of variation is comparable to what I have found at UMFL.

Deterministic model analysis
For each relevant stage (small adults and large adults), I calculated fecundities for years with and without fire. Assuming deterministic geometric growth, I estimated the effect of the frequency of fire-stimulated seedling establishment on population growth by calculating the finite rate of increase, {lambda}. Matrices contained geometric means of fecundity, which varied according to the proportion of years with fire (Table 2). When evaluating the effects of fire frequency on population dynamics, the means of all vital rates other than fecundity were held constant. Using RAMAS EcoLab, {lambda} was calculated by finding the maximum nonnegative eigenvalue (Caswell, 1989 ) for each of five matrices: Annual fires, No fire, and one for each of three matrices with average fire-return intervals of 3, 7, and 20 yr. The 3-yr fire-return interval is typical of the population studied and of most populations at UMFL. In addition to {lambda}, 95% confidence intervals were calculated for each population. These were calculated using standard deviations derived from 500 bootstrapped samples. Expected {lambda}s derived from bootstrapping did not differ appreciably from those generated by RAMAS. Therefore, only {lambda}s produced by RAMAS were presented.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 2. Fixed fecundity rates derived from geometric means as a function of fire frequency

 
To examine the impact of small proportional changes of different fixed vital rates on finite population growth rate ({lambda}), I calculated elasticities (proportional sensitivities) for each vital rate (see de Kroon et al., 1986 ). In addition to elasticities, I performed a loop analysis for each of the matrices (van Groenendael et al., 1994 ) . This was done to examine the impact of changes in unique life-cycle pathways (e.g., early vs. late reproduction) on growth rate.

Stochastic model analysis
To examine the effect of fire-stimulated seedling establishment on population increases and decline, I incorporated environmental stochasticity in vital rates into the projections. Year-to-year stochasticity was produced by randomly sampling from a normally distributed range of vital rates using standard deviations derived from 2–3 yr of empirical data (see Akçakaya, Burgman, and Ginzburg, 1999 ).

Five hundred replications of 20-yr projections were run for each stochastic simulation. I quantified the decline of each population by calculating the proportion of replicate populations that declined to <50% of the original population size in 20 yr. Because I did not incorporate demographic stochasticity in the simulations (i.e., random variation among individuals in the population), results provided underestimates of decline probabilities. Nevertheless, previous work with perennial plants has shown that environmental stochasticity is often much more important than demographic stochasticity, especially in large populations (Menges, 1992 ). In addition to the probability of decline, I examined the probability that a population doubled in size in 20 yr. Initial population sizes were set at 450 individuals (50 seedlings, 125 juveniles, 50 small adults, and 225 large adults, approximating a stable distribution expected for a population experiencing a 3-yr fire-return interval). I assumed no density dependence (see Menges, 1992 ). I did not permit survival rates (i.e., Pi + Gi) to increase above 1 or fall below 0 in any year. However, P4 + V (large adult survival + vegetative reproduction) was allowed to exceed 1, and P4 was truncated at 1. All bootstrapping and simulations were performed on a spreadsheet (Microsoft Excel 98 for Macintosh).

In the demographic analyses, I assumed that fire frequency had no effect on juvenile or adult survivorship or growth (see Brewer, 1999a ). I recognize that long-term fire suppression that enables increased colonization and recruitment of woody species could have a significant negative effect on juvenile and adult survivorship of long-lived perennial herbs (Wells, 1928 ; Wells and Skunk, 1928 ; Brewer, 1998a ; Maliakal, Menges, and Denslow, 2000 ). However, the empirical data in support of woody encroachment of bogs following fire suppression are equivocal (Streng and Harcombe, 1982). There is no convincing experimental evidence that a single fire has an immediate positive or negative effect on the growth or survivorship of juveniles or adults of this species in habitats burned at the frequency currently prescribed at UMFL (see Brewer, 1999a ). At present, there are no published data quantifying the effect of fire frequency on annual rates of adult survivorship in this species. However, as these data become available, they could be incorporated easily into the models.

To examine the sensitivity of population dynamics to proportional changes in the different vital rates, I simulated 38% reductions in all vital rates. This percentage equals the geometric mean reduction in fecundity expected from reducing fire frequency from once every 3 yr to complete fire suppression. In addition, I evaluated the sensitivity of populations to 7% reductions in adult persistence, juvenile persistence, and juvenile growth. Choosing this percentage was an a posteriori decision. Reductions of more than 7% in adult persistence resulted in declining populations. Thus, I used 7% reductions to evaluate the relative importance of adult persistence, juvenile persistence, and juvenile growth on population growth and viability. Statistically significant differences among simulations in the probability of decline or increase were determined for selected comparisons using a chi-square test of independence. Significance values of multiple comparisons were adjusted using Sîdak's multiplicative inequality (Sokal and Rohlf, 1981 ).


    RESULTS
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 LITERATURE CITED
 
Deterministic analysis of population growth and elasticity
The population of Sarracenia I studied at UMFL was projected to grow at a rate of >4% per year ({lambda} = 1.044), assuming fixed vital rates and a fire-return interval of 3 yr (Fig. 2). Increasing fecundity by increasing fire frequency to annual burning increased {lambda} to 1.104 (Fig. 2). Reducing geometric mean fecundity by 38% to levels associated with fire suppression still produced a growing population ({lambda} = 1.028). Populations were projected to grow at rates of 3.4 and 3% per year at fire-return intervals of 7 and 20 yr, respectively (Fig. 2). Confidence intervals associated with all fire frequencies except annual burning contained a stationary population ({lambda} = 1; Fig. 2). Thus, the finite growth rates of these populations were not significantly different from unity.



View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 2. Effect of fire-mediated changes in fecundity on finite population growth rate ({lambda}). Error bars are 95% confidence intervals derived from 500 bootstrapped samples

 
Elasticity analysis showed that population growth was most influenced by changes in the persistence of large adults and, to a lesser extent, changes in juvenile persistence (Fig. 3). Average residence time of large adults was 58.82 yr, compared to 2.78, 5.56, and 1.54 yr for small adults, juveniles, and seedlings, respectively. Population growth did not appear to be particularly sensitive to changes in fecundity (i.e., seedling establishment) or growth (Fig. 3). Results of the loop analysis revealed that population growth was most sensitive to changes in persistence (or stasis, sensu Silvertown et al., 1993 ) and much less sensitive to changes in fecundity or growth by small adults or vegetative reproduction by large adults (Table 3). Furthermore, population growth was more sensitive to sexual reproduction by large adults than sexual reproduction by small adults, suggesting that delayed reproduction may be favored in this species (Table 3).



View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 3. Effects of fire-mediated changes in fecundity on elasticity

 

View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 3. Loop analysis for matrices corresponding to different fire frequencies. Cell entries quantify the percent contribution each unique life-cycle pathway makes to {{lambda}}

 
With increasing fire-return intervals (and thus reduced fecundity), population growth was even more sensitive to changes in adult persistence and less sensitive to changes in juvenile persistence. Elasticities associated with adult persistence increased from 0.45 to 0.66 to 0.71 to 0.74 to 0.75 with increases in fire-return intervals from 1 yr to 3 yr to 7 yr to 20 yr to no fires, respectively (Fig. 3). Elasticities associated with juvenile persistence decreased from 0.18 to 0.11 to 0.09 to 0.08 to 0.07 in response to the same increases in fire-return intervals (Fig. 3).

Stable proportions and reproductive values of stages varied according to fire frequency. As expected, stable stage distributions contained a larger proportion of adults and fewer seedlings as fire frequency decreased (Fig. 4). Distributions in the field were not stable, in large part, because of recurring fires. Seedling densities are higher in years following fire than in other years (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; J. S. Brewer, Laws, and Mozingo, unpublished data). Among post-seedling plants, however, I found that 16% were juveniles, 25% were small adults, and 59% were large adults. This distribution differed somewhat from the stable stage distribution, which contained a greater fraction of juveniles than small adults (see 3-yr fire-return interval in Fig. 4). However, the observed preponderance of large adults is consistent with what would be expected in a population with a stable stage distribution.



View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 4. Effect of fire-mediated changes in fecundity on stable stage distributions and reproductive values

 
Stochastic analysis of population growth and sensitivity
Consistent with the results of the deterministic analysis, stochastic simulations revealed that fire-mediated changes in fecundity influenced population growth. An increase in mean fire-return interval from 3 yr to 7 yr led to a significant decline in the probability of doubling in 20 yr (from 57 to 23.6%, Table 4, {chi}2 = 115.92, P < 0.0001, df = 1). An increase in mean fire-return interval from 7 to 20 did not produce a significant decline in the probability of doubling (from 23.6 to 21.4%, Table 4, {chi}2 = 0.69, adjusted P = 0.97, df = 1). The probability of decline below 50% in 20 yr was <1 in 500, regardless of fire frequency (Table 4).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 4. Effects of reductions in vital rates on population growth and decline; results of stochastic simulations

 
In contrast to the effects of fecundity, reductions in adult persistence reduced population viability. A 7% drop in the persistence of large adults (to 91.4%) in populations burned once every 3 yr increased the probability of decline from <1% to 4% (Table 4). The impact of 38% reductions in adult persistence on population viability was much greater. All replicates declined to less than half the original population size in 20 yr (Table 4). In contrast, neither 7% nor 38% reductions in juvenile persistence increased the probability of decline (Table 4).

Reducing fecundity (by 38%) by removing fire-stimulated increases in seedling establishment had a greater impact on population increase than did reducing juvenile growth by 38% (Table 4; compare no burn to 38% reduction in G2; 20 vs. 36% doubling probability, respectively; {chi}2 = 33.07, P < 0.0001, df = 1). Conversely, a 38% drop in juvenile persistence had a much greater effect on population increase than did a similar reduction in fecundity (Table 4; 8.6 vs. 20%, respectively; {chi}2 = 27.29, P < 0.0001, df = 1).

Juvenile persistence had a much greater effect on population growth than did juvenile growth (Table 4). Reducing the juvenile persistence by 7% significantly reduced the probability of doubling in 20 yr from 57 to 39.6% (Table 4; {chi}2 = 28.94, P < 0.0001, df = 1). In contrast, reducing juvenile growth by 7% did not significantly reduce the probability of doubling in 20 yr (57 vs. 53.2%, Table 4; {chi}2 = 1.46, adjusted P = 0.83, df = 1). The probability of doubling was affected more by reductions in juvenile persistence than by reductions in juvenile growth for large (38%) reductions as well (Table 4).

A 38% reduction in the persistence of small adults produced similar results to an equivalent reduction in juvenile persistence (Table 4). Population growth was not particularly sensitive to 38% reductions in either seedling persistence or vegetative reproduction (Table 4).


    DISCUSSION
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 LITERATURE CITED
 
How important is fire-stimulated seedling establishment to maintaining pitcher plant populations?
Although small increases in fire-return intervals from 3 to 7 yr significantly reduce population growth rates of Sarracenia alata by reducing seedling establishment, fire-stimulated seedling establishment has a modest effect on population dynamics compared to changes in juvenile and adult survival. If one assumed that fire frequency only influenced seedling establishment, then fire frequency would not significantly influence viability of populations at UMFL in the absence of major catastrophes or bottlenecks. Population dynamics are much more sensitive to changes in adult and juvenile survivorship than to changes in fecundity. Population growth may become even more sensitive to changes in adult survivorship as fire frequency decreases (as predicted by the elasticity analysis of the matrix models). Thus, the benefit of increased seedling establishment following a single fire after years of fire suppression may be minimal. It is possible that fire frequency influences juvenile and adult survivorship, but there are insufficient data to evaluate the long-term effects of fire frequency on patterns of survivorship of established pitcher plants. In a previous study (Brewer, 1999a ), I found that the growth and survival of established juveniles and adults are relatively unresponsive to individual fires. Sarracenia exhibited considerable morphological plasticity in response to fire. Individual ramets reduced allocation to pitchers while storing biomass in rhizomes and roots during years between fires, when aboveground biomass associated with neighboring vegetation was greater. This species increased allocation to pitchers, however, immediately following a fire. Bud dormancy and morphological plasticity in allocation to carnivorous structures may enable established ramets of pitcher plants to respond effectively to changes in light availability associated with modest changes in fire regimes (Givnish et al., 1984 ; Zamora, Gómez, and Hódar, 1998 ; Brewer, 1999a ). These different studies of Sarracenia (Barker and Williamson, 1988 ; Brewer, 1999a ) illustrate that examining short-term responses of only one stage of the life cycle of plants to fire provides an incomplete or even misleading picture of the role of fire in maintaining populations of fire-tolerant plants (Bergelson, 1990 ; Brewer, 1999b ). Demographic analyses, such as this one, and long-term experiments are necessary to understand the responses of long-lived plants to fire.

The modest effect of fire-stimulated seedling establishment on the maintenance of Sarracenia populations is entirely consistent with the life history of this species. Demographic patterns in Sarracenia indicate a "stress-tolerator" strategy (Grime, 1977 ). A comparative demographic analysis of 66 plant species from a wide variety of habitats revealed that population growth of stress-tolerators was more sensitive to changes in survival and persistence within stages than to changes in growth or fecundity (Silvertown et al., 1993 ). Given the greater sensitivity of population dynamics of Sarracenia to changes in ramet survival than any other vital rate, more work is needed to investigate potential causes of adult and post-seedling juvenile mortality in this species.

The responses of Sarracenia to fire contrast with those of a short-lived carnivorous species, Drosera capillaris (Brewer, 1999b ). Drosera capillaris shows much higher rates of juvenile and adult mortality than does Sarracenia, owing in part to the former's smaller size and greater vulnerability to burial by shifting sediment (Brewer, 1999b ). In addition, not only do fires increase seedling establishment in Drosera, they also create conditions that increase rates of growth to maturity (Brewer, 1999b ). Thus, the impact of fire on carnivorous plants depends on the life history of the species in question. Nevertheless, despite being relatively short-lived, Drosera capillaris may persist within the habitat during extended periods without fire by lying dormant in a persistent seed bank in the soil (Brewer, 1999b ; J. S. Brewer, unpublished data).

The effects of fire suppression on pitcher-plant populations remain an open question. Open parts of bogs recover quickly from individual fires (in terms of aboveground biomass), and there does not appear to be a significant buildup of aboveground biomass in these areas ~2 yr after a fire until trees become established (Brewer, 1999a ). I hypothesize that pitcher-plant populations are negatively affected by increases in fire-return intervals only insofar as such increases permit increased establishment of trees. The extent to which fire suppression permits tree establishment in pitcher-plant bogs is not known. Streng and Harcombe (1982) argued that edaphic conditions, alone, were sufficient to restrict the establishment of trees in a wet grass–sedge bog in east Texas. I have found that fire suppression of up to 15 yr does not necessarily permit increased establishment of woody species in pitcher plant bogs in Mississippi (J. S. Brewer, unpublished data). Bog sites differ in the rate at which trees become established, due to differences in edaphic conditions (J. S. Brewer, unpublished data; see also Glitzenstein et al., 1995). Pine seedling and sapling mortality are higher in more poorly drained bogs (even in the absence of fire; J. S. Brewer, unpublished data). The rate at which trees become established, in turn, influences the rate at which shrubs and vines become established. Trees provide safe perches for frugivorous birds carrying seeds of long-lived species of shrubs and vines (e.g., Ilex glabra, I. vomitoria, I. coriacea, Gaylussacia mosieri, Smilax laurifolia; Brewer, 1998a ; Ashley and Brewer, 1999 ). Larger perches become the sites of dense, tree-centered thickets (Brewer, 1998a ), which may persist even after the tree dies (J. S. Brewer, personal observations). Species richness of carnivorous plants and the frequency of pitcher plants are significantly lower within these thickets (Brewer, 1998a ). I suggest that this is partly because of the negative effects of woody plants on the survival of established carnivorous plants (Brewer, 1998b ).

The optimal prescribed-fire frequency necessary to maintain carnivorous plant diversity may depend on the productivity of the bog, which in turn is likely to be a function of the hydrologic regime. I suggest that frequent fires (i.e., those occurring more than once a decade) may not be required to reduce tree establishment and thus maintain carnivorous plant communities in the most poorly drained bogs. Nevertheless, attempts at complete fire suppression in these bogs would be risky, unwarranted, and in the long term, impossible (see Streng and Harcombe, 1982). Once woody species get a foothold in a bog, recovery of carnivorous plant communities may require active intervention, involving perhaps mechanical removal of woody species or, at the very least, repeated growing-season fires (Olson and Platt, 1995 ).

Is fire-stimulated seedling establishment relevant to the conservation of rare pitcher plants?
If fire-stimulated seedling establishment has relatively small effects on the maintenance of populations of common species of pitcher plants, as this study indicates, then what role should prescribed burning play in the conservation of rare pitcher plants? To answer this question, one must go beyond the simple demographic analysis presented here and investigate metapopulation dynamics of rare species (see Menges, 1990 ; Schemske et al., 1994 ; Thomas, 1994 ; Hanski and Simberloff, 1997 ). Most pitcher plants and other carnivorous plants have fairly restrictive habitat requirements (e.g., wet, sunny, nutrient-poor bogs and savannas; Givnish et al., 1984 ). Thus, suitable habitat patches may be scattered across the landscape and isolated, with dispersal limitation being potentially severe. Because of low rates of seedling establishment and the prohibitive expense and difficulty of transplanting large numbers of adult ramets, reintroductions will produce very small founder populations that are vulnerable to local extinction. Consequently, one must understand which variables increase rates of seedling establishment following introduction to or colonization of suitable habitat patches.

If fire increases the establishment of seedlings in rare species, as it does in Sarracenia alata, then small reductions in fire-return intervals (from 7 to 3 yr) could significantly promote colonization of suitable habitat patches by increasing population growth rates and buffering small populations from extinction (Huston, 1994 ). Furthermore, some rare species of Sarracenia appear to be predominantly outcrossing plants (Godt and Hamrick, 1996 ). Genetic diversity in pitcher plant populations declines sharply in response to bottlenecks and founder effects in some species (Godt and Hamrick, 1996 ). By adding new genets, fire-stimulated increases in seedling establishment could increase genetic diversity in recovering populations of pitcher plants. Combining the transplantation of a small but genetically diverse sample of adult ramets with frequent prescribed winter burning may provide a relatively cost-effective means of establishing a genetically diverse population of pitcher plants. If the absence of pitcher plants from bogs is the result of habitat deterioration or collection by enthusiasts rather than dispersal limitation, however, then habitat restoration and protection must precede reintroduction efforts (Thomas, 1994 ).


    FOOTNOTES
 
1 The author thanks Allen Albritton and the staff of the University of Mississippi Forest Lands, Josh Grisham, Steven Ashley, Ashley Cain, Allison Grisham, Alex Pabst, and Sean Cralle, and Wendell Haag and two anonymous reviewers for providing constructive comments on this manuscript. Support for this project was provided by a grant from the National Geographic Society #6137-98. Back

2 Author for reprint requests (Fax: 662-915-5144, jbrewer{at}olemiss.edu ). Back


    LITERATURE CITED
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 LITERATURE CITED
 
Akçakaya H. R. M. A. Burgman L. R. Ginzburg 1999 Applied population ecology: principles and computer exercises using RAMAS® EcoLab. Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachussetts, USA

Ashley S. W. J. S. Brewer 1999 Effects of dispersal within and between sites on the distribution of a bird-dispersed shrub in pine flatwoods and savannas. Ecological Society of America Annual Meeting Abstracts: 44

Barker N. G. G. B. Williamson 1988 Effects of a winter fire on Sarracenia alata and S. psittacina. American Journal of Botany 75: 138-143[CrossRef][ISI]

Bergelson J. 1990 Life after death: site pre-emption by the remains of Poa annua. Ecology 71: 2157-2165[CrossRef][ISI]

Brewer J. S. 1998a Patterns of plant species richness in wet slash pine (Pinus elliottii) savanna. Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society 125: 216-224[CrossRef][ISI]

———. 1998b Effects of competition and litter on a carnivorous plant, Drosera capillaris (Droseraceae). American Journal of Botany 85: 1592-1596[Abstract/Free Full Text]

———. 1999a Short-term effects of fire and competition on growth and plasticity of the yellow pitcher plant, Sarracenia alata (Sarraceniaceae). American Journal of Botany 86: 1264-1271[Abstract/Free Full Text]

———. 1999b Effects of fire, competition, and soil disturbances on regeneration of a carnivorous plant (Drosera capillaris). American Midland Naturalist 141: 28-42[CrossRef][ISI]

———. 1999c Effects of competition, litter, and disturbance on an annual carnivorous plant (Utricularia juncea). Plant Ecology 140: 159-165[CrossRef][ISI]

Brockway D. G. C. E. Lewis 1997 Long-term effects of dormant-season prescribed fire on plant community diversity, structure and productivity in a longleaf pine wiregrass ecosystem. Forest Ecology and Management 96: 167-183[CrossRef][ISI]

Caswell H. 1989 Matrix population models. Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachusetts, USA

de Kroon H. A. Plaisier J. von Groendendael H. Caswell 1986 Elasticity: the relative contribution of demographic parameters to population growth rate. Ecology 67: 1427-1431[CrossRef][ISI]

Eleuterius L. N. 1968 Floristics and ecology of coastal bogs in Mississippi. M.S. thesis, University of Southern Mississippi, Hattiesburg, Mississippi, USA

Ellison A. M. 2001 Interspecific and intraspecific variation in seed size and germination requirements of Sarracenia (Sarraceniaceae). American Journal of Botany 88: 429–437

Folkerts G. W. 1982 The Gulf Coast pitcher plant bogs. American Scientist 70: 260-267

Gibson T. C. 1983 Competition, disturbance, and the carnivorous plant community in the southeastern United States. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA

Gilliam F. S. N. L. Christensen 1986 Herb-layer response to burning in pine flatwoods of the lower Coastal Plain of South Carolina. Bulletin of the Torrey Botanical Club 113: 42-45[CrossRef][ISI]

Givnish T. J. 1989 Ecology and evolution of carnivorous plants. In W. G. Abrahamson [ed.], Plant–animal interactions, 243–290. McGraw-Hill, New York, New York, USA

———, E. L. Burkhardt R. E. Happel J. D. Weintraub 1984 Carnivory in the bromeliad Brocchinia reducta, with a cost/benefit model for the general restriction of carnivorous plants to sunny, moist, nutrient-poor habitats. American Naturalist 124: 479-497[CrossRef][ISI]

Godt M. J. J. L. Hamrick 1996 Genetic structure of two endangered pitcher plants, Sarracenia jonesii and Sarracenia oreophila (Sarraceniaceae). American Journal of Botany 83: 1016-1023[CrossRef][ISI]

Grime J. P. 1977 Evidence for the existence of three primary strategies in plants and its relevance to ecological and evolutionary theory. American Naturalist 111: 1169-1194[CrossRef][ISI]

Hanski I. A. D. Simberloff 1997 The metapopulation approach, its history, conceptual domain, and application to conservation. In I. A. Hanski and M. E. Gilpin [eds.], Metapopulation biology, ecology, genetics, and evolution, 5–26. Academic Press, San Diego, California, USA

Huston M. A. 1994 Biological diversity: the coexistence of species on changing landscapes. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK

Lefkovitch L. P. 1965 The study of population growth in organisms grouped by stages. Biometrics 21: 1-18[CrossRef][ISI]

Maliakal S. K. E. S. Menges J. S. Denslow 2000 Community composition and regeneration of Lake Wales Ridge wiregrass flatwoods in relation to time-since-fire. Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society 127: 125-138[CrossRef][ISI]

McDaniel S. 1971 The genus Sarracenia (Sarraceniaceae). Bulletin of the Tall Timbers Research Station 9: 1-38

Menges E. 1990 Population viability analysis for an endangered plant. Conservation Biology 4: 41-62

———. 1992 Stochastic modeling of extinction in plant populations. In P. L. Fiedler and S. K. Jain [eds.], Conservation biology: the theory and practice of nature conservation, preservation and management, 253–275. Chapman and Hall, New York, New York, USA

Norquist C. 1984 A comparative study of the soils and vegetation of savannas in Mississippi. M.S. thesis, Mississippi State University, Mississippi State, Mississippi, USA

Olson M. S. W. J. Platt 1995 Effects of habitat and growing season fires on resprouting of shrubs in longleaf pine savannas. Vegetatio 119: 101-118[CrossRef][ISI]

Rebertus A. J. G. B. Williamson E. B. Moser 1989 Longleaf pine pyrogenicity and turkey oak mortality in Florida xeric sandhills. Ecology 70: 60-70[CrossRef][ISI]

Schemske D. et al 1994 Evaluating approaches to the conservation of rare and endangered plants. Ecology 75: 584-606[CrossRef][ISI]

Schnell D. E. 1976 Carnivorous plants of the United States and Canada. John F. Blair, Winston-Salem, North Carolina, USA

Silvertown J. M. Franco I. Pisanty A. Mendoza 1993 Comparative plant demography—relative importance of life-cycle components to the finite rate of increase in woody and herbaceous perennials. Journal of Ecology 81: 465-476[CrossRef][ISI]

Sokal R. R. F. J. Rohlf 1981 Statistical tables. 2nd ed. W. H. Freeman, New York, New York, USA

Thomas C. D. 1994 Extinction, colonization, and metapopulations: environmental tracking by rare species. Conservation Biology 8: 373-378

van Groenendael J. H. de Kroon S. Kalisz S. Tuljapurkar 1994 Loop analysis: evaluating life history pathways in population projection matrices. Ecology 75: 2410-2415[CrossRef][ISI]

Waldrop T. A. D. L. White S. M. Jones 1992 Fire regimes for pine–grassland communities in the southeastern United States. Forest Ecology and Management 47: 195-210[CrossRef][ISI]

Walker J. R. K. Peet 1983 Composition and species diversity of pine–wiregrass savannas of the Green Swamp, North Carolina. Vegetatio 55: 163-179[CrossRef][ISI]

Weiss T. E., Jr. 1980 The effects of fire and nutrient availability on the pitcher plant Sarracenia flava L. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia, USA

Wells B. W. 1928 Plant communities of the coastal plain of North Carolina and their successional relations. Ecology 9: 230-242[CrossRef][ISI]

———, and I. V. Skunk 1928 A Southern upland grass–sedge bog. North Carolina Agricultural Experiment Station Technical Bulletin 32: 1075

Zamora R. J. M. Gómez J. A. Hódar 1998 Fitness responses of a carnivorous plant in contrasting ecological scenarios. Ecology 79: 1630-1644[ISI]





This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Submit a response
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me when eLetters are posted
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (16)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Brewer, J. S.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Brewer, J. S.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Brewer, J. S.


HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS